In her second novel, The Autograph Man, Zadie Smith has set herself the unenviable task of following up a certain segment of recent literary history. Her first novel, the bestselling, award-laden and much-hyped White Teeth wore its ambitions lightly: an exuberant comic foray into the lives of three disparate families living in suburban north London, it dealt simultaneously--and deftly--with wider multicultural and political motifs.

The Autograph Man has a similar ebullience and an equally dazzling panoply of characters. Its hero Alex Li-Tandem is "one of this generation who watch themselves", a Chinese-Jewish north Londoner who is first introduced as a child accompanying his father to a wrestling match between those two larger-than-life scions of 1970s Saturday afternoon television--Big Daddy and Giant Haystacks. When Alex's father dies in the pandemonium surrounding the pursuit of Big Daddy's autograph, the twin themes of the novel are launched--one is the bereaved Alex's search for a replacement to fill the gulf, the other his obsession with tracking down, buying and selling autographs. Alex seeks one autograph in particular and seemingly in vain--that of Kitty Alexander, a fading film star. The route he follows in his search has much to say about the nature of celebrity and the privacy of souls, of fantasy and reality--all narrated in Smith's breathless prose.

The Autograph Man plays on many strands and clever observations--in particular Jewishness, goyishness and Zen Buddhism. Smith is a superbly assured writer whose images stick in the mind; for example, Alex's girlfriend Esther has "hair plaited like a puzzle". The dialogue is vivid and there is much humour but at times the convoluted plot threatens to spill over into anarchy and the humour can be self-conscious. Though this does not diminish the entertainment value of The Autograph Man, it does--frustratingly--make it appear insincere. --Catherine Taylor

2008-11-03 A pretentious and disappointing follow-up to White Teeth

After her impressive debut novel White Teeth and the hype surrounding it there was always a danger that Zadie Smith would join the ranks of literary Establishment luvvies and begin penning works more unstructured and impenetrable under the pretence of `pushing back the boundaries of creativity'. This has almost happened with the disjointed and rather pretentious Autograph Man, though it is saved by regular injections of sardonic humour.
Stimulated by a visit to a celebrity wrestling match with his dad, Chinese-Jewish boy Alex Li-Tandem grows up to become an professional autograph dealer with one elusive Hollywood signature as his Holy Grail. Its possession would change his life. Although The Autograph Man is generally regarded as a swipe at the vacuous nature of celebrity obsession the protagonist is really more of an anally-retentive collector of trivia and memorabilia than an obsessive celeb freak. Zadie's novel is original and inventive but with the characters being little more than names on a page, and no convincing sense of place or time, it is all too long and cold and the interest cannot be sustained. And I am not sure what was gained by making all the characters Jewish other than to cloak the work with an aura of faux-Hebraic mysticism. Overall assessment: disappointing, but an extra star for The Joke about the Pope and the Chief Rabbi.