2008-06-28 Portrait of the monster as a young man

A fascinating portrait of Stalin as a young man. Up till now, it has been difficult to assess the life of the Soviet dictator before 1917. The hagiography of Soviet times absurdly exalted him; Trotsky, on the other hand, belittled his role in Russia's revolutionary movement. Western historians tended to agree with Trostky, despite his obvious grudges against the man who ultimately ordered him killed. During Soviet times, sources seemed inaccessible to western historians, but British historian Montefiore had been surprisingly successful in finding a lot of material about Stalin's early life, including unpublished (or unknown in the west) autobiographies of some of Stalin's partners in crime. Montefiore's key insight is that to understand Stalinist Russia you have to imagine a country led by a gangster. Stalin cut his teeth as the leader of the Bolshevik underground in the Caucasus, where his gang engaged in bank robberies, extortions and bombings (including one in Tbilissi in 1907 that left dozens of bystanders dead). Once in power, he behaved like a gangster, exterminating his opponents and becoming paranoid about possible informers (spies) in his organization (the Okhrana, Czarist Russia's secret police had been highly successful in infiltrating Russian revolutionaries).
Trotsky held that Stalin was virtually unknown among Bolsheviks before 1917, but far from that, from 1905 on, he was their point man in the Caucasus (though, because he led a clandestine life, few knew him by his real name, addressing him instead through a variety of alias, like Soso and Koba). Lenin had a high opinion of Stalin, feeling his ruthlessness was just what the Bolsheviks needed.
Stalin was certainly ruthless, but he was no brute, as Trotsky held. The seminary where he studied (and where he got excellent grades) was one of Georgia's premiere educational institutions. And he was a voracious reader for most of his life. Trotsky's spite was at being beaten in the power game by someone he considered to be less intelligent than himself, but Trotsky's view of Stalin as an ignorant and mediocre apparatchik is hard to held.
Stalin was also very much a man of Georgia. Up to the time he was about 35, he spend almost his whole life in his native country, absorbing its Mediterranean clannish and violent culture.
Many juicy stories are included in the book. Stalin spent most of World War I in internal exile in the remote Siberian north. He lived in a small settlement by the Yenisey river, surrounded by Samoyedic tribes with whom he liked to hunt in the area's pristine forests. There, he also fathered a boy with a 13 year old girl living in the area. When Czar Nicholas II abdicated in early 1917, Stalin was still in Siberia (Lenin and Trotsky were outside Russia). The life of exiles in Siberia during the Czar's regime, by the way, was surprisingly mild. Many were able to escape, including Stalin, several times.
Though the book stops at 1917, it leaves little doubt as who would come on top on the power struggle after Lenin's death. Stalin was far better at cultivating people than the arrogant Trotsky, even if he would later turn on them and send them to the firing squad.